Mindpocket

Journaling

Voice journaling: how to start when writing feels like a chore

Talking is faster than typing, and it skips the blank page. How to start a voice journal in one minute a day, and how to keep the recordings from piling up unheard.

A magpie calls out from a garden gate at dusk beside a small brass bell that glows

Alex bought a lovely notebook in January, and it has four entries, every one of them from the first week. It isn't that Alex has nothing to say. It's the fuss in between: get the book out, hunt for a pen that works, look at the empty page, work out a first line. Somewhere in there the thought wanders off and the kettle clicks.

Talking cuts most of that out. You're holding your phone anyway, and you've been talking since you were two.

Why talking can feel easier than writing

Start with speed. In a lab study of short messages typed or spoken into an iPhone, people got English text in roughly three times faster by voice than by keyboard, 153 words a minute against 52 (Ruan and colleagues, 2018).

How fast words get onto a phone
  • Talking153 words a minute
  • Typing52 words a minute

Ruan and colleagues, 2018, English, short phrases spoken or typed into an iPhone. The best case for voice.

To be fair to the keyboard, they were copying phrases they'd been given, not thinking aloud, so read that as the best case. Even so, it's a big gap.

The blank page matters too. When you write, you have to settle on an opening sentence before anything else happens. When you talk, "right, so, today was weird" is a perfectly good opening, and you can find out what you meant halfway through.

There's also less to keep track of when your days are all over the place. The US National Institute of Mental Health and the NHS both include being easily distracted or forgetful, and finding it hard to organise your time, among the signs of ADHD in adults. Think about what a paper journal quietly expects: the notebook, a pen, and a free half hour somewhere quiet, all lined up before you've said anything. Recording a voice memo takes a single tap.

Is talking really as good as writing?

Honestly, hardly anyone has tested this head to head, and the studies we have are small and a few decades old.

Back in 1994, Murray and Segal asked people to either talk or write about a painful experience, in 20-minute sessions spread over four days. The two groups worked through it in much the same way, and the subject got less painful for both as the days went by. The ones talking let more emotion show. Something people forget to mention: both groups felt worse right after each session. A recording isn't a pick-me-up, at least not in the moment.

Then in 2006, Lyubomirsky and colleagues had students write, talk into a tape recorder, or simply think about the worst thing that had happened to them, for 15 minutes a day across three days. When they were checked four weeks later, the writers and the talkers were more satisfied with their lives than the ones who had only thought about it. With their happiest experience, life satisfaction flipped: just thinking it over beat writing or talking about it. In a third study, students who picked apart a happy day in writing ended up with lower well-being and health scores than students who just replayed it in their heads.

Nobody in these studies was being looked at for ADHD, and none of them involved an app. So the takeaway is a modest one. Saying something out loud seems to do roughly what writing it down does. And when a day goes well, I'd skip the analysis and just enjoy it.

How to start: one minute, one moment, one question

You don't need a morning ritual with a candle and a nice mug. What works is way smaller than that.

  1. Pick a moment you already have. It might be the walk from the station, the parked car, or standing there while the kettle boils. The point is that it happens whether you remember the journal or not.
  2. Set the bar at one minute. A minute is the target. If you're on a roll, keep talking, and if you dry up at 40 seconds, I'd still count it.
  3. Start with one question. Keep it the same for the first few weeks so there's nothing to decide. "What's on my mind right now?" works. So does "What happened today that I'd forget by Friday?"
  4. Don't listen back yet. Stop, pocket the phone, get on with your day.
One minute a day, round and round
  1. A moment you already havethe walk home, the parked car
  2. Record one minutefrom one plain question
  3. Name it with one wordWork, Ellie, home, idea
  4. One thing for tomorrowtext Jo back

and again tomorrow

Leo does his between the bus stop and his front door, which is about ten minutes, earbuds in, phone stuffed in his coat pocket, and anyone walking past just assumes he's ringing someone (hehe, perfect cover).

What to say when you don't know what to say

Often the one question is enough to get going, but now and then you'll open the app and sit there looking at the red button thinking: idk. Fair. Keep a few spare questions in a note for those days: what's taking up the most room in my head, what someone told me today that I want to hang on to, what I'm putting off (and what the first tiny bit of it would be), what went better than I expected, and what I'd tell Sam if this were happening to them.

If none of them land, just tell the day from the start, the way you would if Mum rang to ask how it went, and something nearly always snags halfway. And on days when your head's too crowded to pick anything, do a spoken brain dump instead, everything in whatever order it comes, until it goes quiet.

Avoid the voice memo graveyard

This is the part the app websites mostly skip. Plenty of people who give voice journaling a go end up, a few months in, with a phone full of files called "New Recording 47" that never get played, and people on ADHD forums describe exactly that. Making a recording takes seconds. Getting anything out of one later is slow, though, because there's no way to glance down audio like you'd glance down a page.

Three small habits sort out most of it.

  • Turn on transcripts. If you've got an iPhone 12 or later, Apple's Voice Memos app can show you a transcript of each recording (in supported languages), and its search goes through the transcripts as well as the titles. So you can type "Ellie" or "dentist" and end up on the right day.
  • Name it with one word as you stop. Things like "Work", "Ellie", "home" or "idea". Two seconds, and a list of names is far more use than a column of dates.
  • End with one thing for tomorrow. Finish every recording on a line like "Tomorrow, one thing: text Jo back." That way even one you never hear again has done something, and you can pick one small next step out of a ten-minute ramble without sorting all of it.

If you can, spend five minutes scrolling the week's transcripts on a Sunday. Jobs go wherever your tasks already live. Things about people (a birthday, a book someone recommended) go where you'll see them before you next meet, and a second brain is only any use if it's one place. When a recording turns out to be mostly a list of jobs, everything in what to do after a brain dump works on it too.

Voice or writing: the honest trade-offs

I don't think either one wins. They're good at different things.

Voice is better for:

  • Getting started when you're worn out, out walking, or carrying the shopping.
  • Talking a feeling through, since your tone carries things the words alone wouldn't.
  • Catching what fades fast, like what a friend just told you.

Writing is better for:

  • Finding things later, because a page can be skimmed in seconds.
  • Working out a plan, when it helps to see the steps next to each other.
  • Privacy, since you can't always speak freely on a train or in a shared home.
Voice or writing, at a glance

Voice

Getting started
Easy, even on a walk
A feeling
Your tone carries it
Finding it later
Slow without a transcript
A plan
Hard to see the steps
Privacy
Not on a train

Writing

Getting started
Needs a pen, and a quiet minute
A feeling
The words alone
Finding it later
Skim a page in seconds
A plan
The steps side by side
Privacy
Anywhere

Lots of people do both, talking in the moment and then reading the transcript and adding a line or two when they get a minute. If you're not sure which one today calls for, have a look at how a brain dump, a to-do list and a journal differ.

When it doesn't stick

"I feel silly talking to my phone." Hold it to your ear like you're on a call, and honestly, nobody will look twice. In the car nobody can hear you anyway.

"I forget to do it." Nine times out of ten the moment is too vague. "In the evening" slips past without you noticing, but "when I turn the engine off" has a way of sticking.

"I did it for a week and stopped." So does nearly everyone, and there's no streak to mourn. Do a minute tomorrow. A journal with gaps in it still counts.

"It keeps turning into a complaint." Nudge the last sentence towards one thing that went fine, or one thing for tomorrow. If you're still coming out of it feeling worse, give it a rest for a while and talk to someone you trust, or a doctor.

"I never want to hear these again." You don't have to. Delete the lot every Sunday if you like; the useful bit was saying it.

Where Mindpocket fits

We make Mindpocket, an iPhone app built first for ADHD minds, so here's an honest account of where it fits. You tell it things as they happen, whether that's a voice memo, a note, a photo, a screenshot or a link. It files what you said into a map of the people, plans and ideas in your life, which means the part about Ellie lands with Ellie and the part about the trip lands with the trip. It turns "I really should…" into one doable next step on Today when it's time, and Chat answers questions from your own life and shows where each answer came from.

Because it's an AI, it'll get things wrong now and then. It tells you when something is only a suggestion, and it waits for your yes. What you share stays in the EU, there are no ads, and it's never sold.

You don't need it to keep a voice journal, to be clear. Voice Memos with transcripts switched on, plus a five-minute look on a Sunday, does the job for nothing. Mindpocket is for the days you'd rather the sorting got done without you.

Questions

Is voice journaling as good as writing?

For getting thoughts out, the little research we have says the two are close. In one small 1994 study, people who talked about a hard experience worked through it in much the same way as people who wrote about it. Writing is quicker to skim afterwards, which is why a lot of people talk first and read the transcript later.

How long should a voice journal entry be?

A minute is plenty to start with. Some days you'll ramble on for ten, and that's fine too. The bar should be low enough that you'd still clear it on a rotten day.

Do I need a special app for voice journaling?

No. On an iPhone 12 or later, the built-in Voice Memos app can show a transcript and search it, and that covers the basics for free. Pay for an app only if it does something with the recordings you know you'd never get round to doing yourself.

What if I hate the sound of my own voice?

Almost everyone does at first, hehe. You never have to listen back: read the transcript, or don't open old entries at all. Getting it said was the whole point.

Sources

  1. NIMH: ADHD in Adults: 4 Things to Know
  2. NHS: ADHD in adults
  3. Ruan, Wobbrock, Liou, Ng and Landay (2018). Comparing speech and keyboard text entry for short messages in two languages on touchscreen phones. Proceedings of the ACM on Interactive, Mobile, Wearable and Ubiquitous Technologies, 1(4).
  4. Murray and Segal (1994). Emotional processing in vocal and written expression of feelings about traumatic experiences. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 7(3), 391 to 405.
  5. Lyubomirsky, Sousa and Dickerhoof (2006). The costs and benefits of writing, talking, and thinking about life's triumphs and defeats. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(4), 692 to 708.
  6. Apple Support: View a transcription in Voice Memos on iPhone

Keep reading